Herman Zapf was a bit surprised when his Palatino design became a big hit as a text font. It was intended as a display face, for titles and headings, and he was busy developing the text version, Aldus, that was intended to pair with it. Maybe he should have let the public see that one first!
I have a version of Aldus in my type collection and I would definitely use it rather than Palatino for text in a novel. I did set my very first novel, The Middle of Nowhere, in Palatino, being somewhat less knowledgeable at the time. It looks okay but it does not have the readability of some other choices. Palatino will definitely slow down the eye, though admittedly not that much.
I don’t use the typeface for fiction body text now, but it is my default for poetry — when in doubt, print that poem in Palatino. Typically, I would print that a point or two larger than in a novel, which better suits a display face. And, of course, I do not want the reader to rush through the poems so I’m not interested in quick readability.
I would certainly not discourage anyone from using Palatino for a novel or story collection. It is a well-crafted and attractive design; if you like it, use it!



